Is Platform Capitalism Actually The Hereafter Of The Humanitarian Sector?

I read New York, Barcelona or Berlin), a painting present emerges that many vulnerable workers are genuinely worse off due to said platforms.
I discovery it hard to come across how charities, non-governmental organizations as well as humanitarian actors that yesteryear their really mandate engage alongside marginalized, vulnerable constituents should mirror parts of their operations later on these platforms.

But likewise these broader philosophical issues I also lead hold some to a greater extent than detailed points of critique that volition follow the menses of Paula’s master post:

Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 platform recognises its biggest asset is non the existent estate nor the intellectual property, it is the intangible network of people who demand services as well as those who tin deliver them.

I would larn every bit far every bit rephrasing the judgement every bit follows: ‘A platform recognizes that existent estate as well as infrastructure are expensive to create as well as keep as well as outsources these problems to its quasi-employees or 3rd parties, i.e. the government’.
But humanitarian aid yesteryear Definition takes house inward an surroundings where infrastructure no longer exists or never existed inward the starting fourth dimension place. And connecting ‘both sides’ is easier said than done as well as either involves a lot of vetting or volition attract the equivalent of an regular army of Deliveroo delivery people to the aid industry; talking well-nigh professionalization…

Are NGOs gear upward to transform information into our most valuable asset?

I would similar to come across evidence that supports the claim that NGOs lead hold valuable data. Sure, they lead hold some data, but that information is collected inward remote locations as well as from ‘poor people’ which raises huge questions well-nigh information character as well as the value of that data.
Facebook every bit a platform makes coin yesteryear convincing advertisers that their coin is well-spent. Many NGOs lead hold expertise (and data) well-nigh specific, relatively modest contexts as well as comparison them inward a key database could hold upward interesting, but involves huge investments, synchronization of collection tools etc. In the end, in that location is entirely 1 Uber inward the city-not 25…

NGOs volition hold upward valued non entirely yesteryear the amount of cash grants they deal to disburse, but yesteryear the size of their networks as well as the positive connections made betwixt actors inward each especial surroundings field delivering the cash grant (be it beneficiaries, local NGOS, individual sector, government, etc.)

This does non audio too bad inward theory, but inward practise it is much to a greater extent than complicated. I definitely admit the benefits of cash transfers as well as at the same fourth dimension desire to stress that every bit most other debates inward evolution things tin hold upward quite complicated.
Bringing together proprietary information from individual companies, non open-access regime information as well as from ‘beneficiaries’ similar a shot raises questions well-nigh reliability, comparability as well as cooperation. I also lead hold difficulties seeing how non-governmental organizations should hold upward set inward accuse of this chore as well as how they are qualified to function alongside conflicting interests of stakeholders permit lone information protection issues. Data is sensitive, but also really political.

imagine if humanitarians responsibly analysed the information nosotros collect anyway on beneficiary needs, as well as used it to empathise them as well as their contexts as well as hence good nosotros would know what beneficiaries demand earlier they demand it.

As my colleague Linnet Taylor is disputation inward a lot of her research, precisely exporting the complicated, politicized ‘Northern’ debates of information mightiness to the global ‘South’ volition most probable hateful replicating our problems or as well as hence rights, opting-out, regime surveillance etc. And fifty-fifty if nosotros larn out the legal as well as policy frameworks aside, I discovery it hard to come across how you lot could collect information in, say, Republic of Chad or the Central African Republic alongside a character that would allow behavioral targeting as well as prediction.

How do nosotros hook upward alongside information protection, cyber safety as well as humanitarian principles into operational standards?

In the end, the large problems are non the starting fourth dimension 2 issues: information protection as well as safety could hold upward solved; but the insurmountable challenge lies inward the ‘humanitarian principles’: Amazon precisely started deliveries inward Australia as well as it volition hold upward interesting to come across how it tin bargain alongside the country’s remote challenges. And if AirB’nB hosts lead hold a style to discriminate against certainly user groups it poses novel challenges for the platform inward damage of liability as well as other consequences.
The bigger indicate is that algorithms, the powerful fuel of platforms, tin hold upward biased.
Ultimately, the challenge is that humanitarian aid principles as well as NGO function cannot compromise, they lead hold to larn to the distant, remote, destroyed places, the ‘loss makers’ inhabited yesteryear people who volition unlikely to hold upward transformed into consumers whatever fourth dimension soon.

To cutting a long flush short: I would hold upward a flake to a greater extent than careful inward predicting a futurity of the humanitarian sector based on data-driven cash programs where NGOs mimic global capitalistic platforms.

I would also similar to come across a much to a greater extent than critical engagement alongside the concept of platform capitalism as well as the (hidden/outsourced) toll inward an ‘industry’ that yesteryear Definition should function for the marginalized delivery somebody rather than the Silicon Valley hedge fund manager.

Ideals as well as practices based on social justice, equality as well as changing mightiness relations should ever guide the function of NGOs-and sometimes those efforts cannot hold upward precisely measured yesteryear information collected along the provide chain...